Did they leave out the inner sleeve? Plus that card looks a little short compared to the ones I have. I will post pics later to give you an idea what I'm talking about. I wasn't too happy with my one experince with BVG either. That's when I turned to SGC for the older stuff.
A few years ago at the National I saw a 1938 Goudey Rudy York reprint in a BVG holder. The dealer wanted $75 for it. When I explained - very politely - that he had a reprint, he explained to me - very impolitely - that I would be better off shopping at another table.