He's getting a no sale because the card stinks compared to the Sgc 84 that was being sold.
I agree with Aconte. That card lacks eye appeal. I also agree with Greg. I'm surprised the card didn't get an OC. Regardless, if the reserve is anywhere near the BIN, I'd be surprised if the card sold.
Here's a thought...perhaps an important component of any hobby "gold standard" is the precise half-point grading scale. In my opinion, any grading company that lacks it, cannot be a viable long-term competitor.