Loc: Santa Monica, CA
Typical behavior of Dude and Toppsgun. They take after the fella they worship. Assign blame and never admit when you are wrong. They should be excussed for being mindless but we should extend some understanding for their being clueless. They do spend a good deal of time with their heads in the sand.
#358647 - 03/03/0404:14 PMRe: NEWEST POST FROM ACROSS THE STREET
Bid more or post more... tough one...
Loc: On The Beach....where else!
That litmus test is rather small but I understand your point. I'm just wondering if the graders are unsure how to grade at times. The cards that were graded trimmed now is a concern. I wonder if the mistake is now and the cards should be ex or ex/mt or before and that they should not of been graded. Also, I know the submitter said he took great care cracking out the cards but we don't know if he damaged the card that went from a 5 to a 4. With some cards it might not take much. And then finally grading is subjective!
Anyhow, the sample size was small. So who knows. You want a litmus test....
Stay tuned... Maybe after the Fort show I'll share.
You are correct. The sample is small and it does not represent a broad or comprehensive selection of re-submitted PSA cards; however, I do not feel that this re-submission is an aberration. That is why I chose the words "litmus test" -- a single indicator that reveals a greater scientific or physical reality.
I look forward to seeing your results...keep up posted!