I recently subbed my Lord of the Rings autograph cards from BGS. I have been thinking of slowly moving all my BGS graded into SGC. Now I am not so sure.

1 2001 Topps SIR IAN HOLM Lord Of The Rings Auto. 92 GAI 8.5 even
2 2001 Topps LIV TYLER Lord Of The Rings Auto. 96 Raw
3 2001 Topps SIR IAN MCKELLEN Lord Of The Rings Auto. 92 Raw
4 2001 Topps HUGO WEAVING Lord Of The Rings Auto. 96 BGS 8.5 up 1
5 2001 Topps CHRISTOPHER LEE Lord Of The Rings Auto. 88 BGS 9.0 down 2
6 2003 Topps BERNARD HILL Lord Of The Rings Auto. 96 BGS 9.0 even
7 2003 Topps KARL URBAN Lord Of The Rings Auto. 96 BGS 9.0 even
8 2003 Topps JOHN NOBLE Lord Of The Rings Auto. 84 Raw
9 2003 Topps BRUCE HOPKINS Lord Of The Rings Auto. 88 BGS 9.5 down 3 cen9.5,cor9.0,ed9.5,sur9.5
10 2003 Topps CHRISTOPHER LEE Lord Of The Rings Auto. 96 Raw
11 2003 Topps ANDY SERKIS Lord Of The Rings Auto. (Update) 96 BGS 9.0 even
12 2003 Topps SEAN BEAN Lord Of The Rings Auto. (Update) 84 Raw
13 2003 Topps VIGGO MORTENSEN Lord Of The Rings Auto. (Update) 86 BGS 8.5 down 2
14 2002 Topps BILLY BOYD Lord Of The Rings Auto. 96 BGS 8.5 up 1
15 2002 Topps DAVID WENHAM Lord Of The Rings Auto. 88 BGS 8.0 even
16 2002 Topps MIRANDA OTTO Lord Of The Rings Auto. 80 BGS 7.5 down 3 cen 9.5,cor7.0,ed8.5,sur9.5
17 2002 Topps DOMINIC MONAGHAN Lord Of The Rings Auto. 70 Raw (Grrr!!)
18 2002 Topps CRAIG PARKER Lord Of The Rings Auto. 84 BGS 8.5 down 3 cen9.5,cor8.5,ed8.5,sur9.5
19 2002 Topps CATE BLANCHETT Lord Of The Rings Auto. 88 BGS 9.0 down 2
20 2002 Topps SEAN ASTIN Lord Of The Rings Auto. 96 BGS 8.5 up 1
21 2002 Topps ORLANDO BLOOM Lord Of The Rings Auto. 96 BGS 9.0 even
22 2002 Topps ELIJAH WOOD Lord Of The Rings Auto. 84 BGS 8.5 down 3 cen9.5,cor8,ed8.5,sur9.0

Do I chalk this up to SGC just doesn't have any experience with these cards? They are all population one now in their registry. Beckett really that bad? These are supposed to be in Beckett's wheelhouse, modern shiney. I may just crack and put them in one-touches and call it a day. I can put up a few scans when I get them back.